RULES/ REGS

e-mail   print   reprint   share   Login to Recommend

Power Company Cleared of Cash Balance Conversion Miscue

November 5, 2008 (PLANSPONSOR.com) - A Newark, Delaware, power company did not have to tell workers when it converted its defined benefit pension plan to a cash balance program because the change was not expected to cut employees' benefits, a federal appellate court ruled.

The 3 rd  U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals asserted in a decision involving a cash balance challenge against Pepco Holdings and its subsidiary, Conectiv, that the conversion did not violate the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA). The appellate panel decided that because the plan change was not "reasonably expected to significantly reduce" employees' future benefits, ERISA Section 204(h) did not mandate an employee notice the conversion was taking place.

The section provides that participants must receive 15 days' notice prior to a plan amendment that results in a significant reduction in the rate of future benefit accrual.

In reaching its decision, the court was persuaded by expert testimony on behalf of Pepco, the parent company, which used an assumption that participants' wages would experience zero growth.

According to the appeals court, during trial the defendants' expert witness calculated that future benefits at retirement for each individual would be expected to increase, instead of decrease, under the new cash balance plan if salaries were held constant at 1999 levels. An expert for the participants argued against this "zero growth" in wages used by the defendants' expert and instead testified that future benefits decreased when using a 4.5% salary growth assumption.

The case is   Charles v. Pepco Holdings Inc., 3d Cir., No. 07-4044, unpublished 11/4/08.

Fred Schneyer
editors@plansponsor.com

Retirement Resource Center

Searching for Retirement Advice

Click here for our video interview with Jon Prescott, Chief Marketing Officer, CPI Qualified Plan Consultants.

Retirement Resource Center

Retirement Insights

At PLAN DESIGNS 2009, PLANSPONSOR met with Steve Smith, VP, Sales & Corporate Plans Market Leader, Diversified Investment Advisors

Retirement Resource Center

To advertise here...

...please call Hayward Henderson at 203-979-6195 (m), or click here to send hhenderson@assetinternational.com an email inquiry.
Site Map  About Us  Advertiser Services  Subscriber Services  Terms of Use  Privacy Policy  FAQS  Glossary  Customer Service

Copyright ©1989-2010    Asset International, Inc.    All Rights Reserved. No Reproduction without Prior Authorization

GfJ432Hghb43dfs3dasds4at8