For more stories like this, sign up for the PLANSPONSOR NEWSDash daily newsletter.
DC Returns Down, But Outpace Major Equity Indexes in Q3
The best returns for the quarter were found in the self-directed brokerage account segment of the Security Trust Company (STC) Quarterly Defined Contribution Investment Returns Index, which reported an average loss of 5.81% for the quarter, somewhat better than the 6.34% loss from the prior quarter (see SDA, Core Returns Suffer in Q2 ).
Separately managed options lost 7.54%, while selections among core mutual fund investment options lost 8.78%, on average, according to the STC index, which tracks the performance of nearly 1500 defined contribution plans, representing $7.2 billion in assets and an estimated 540,000 participants.
Those results compared favorably with the 17.24% loss registered by the S&P 500, as well as the 17.39% loss for the Dow, and the near 20% tumble for the NASDAQ.
Bond “Yields”
Within the STC Index itself, bond funds and money market/stable value funds were the only categories to show positive returns for both the quarter and year-to-date. For the quarter bond investments in the STC Index notched a 2.84% gain, while money market/stable value funds eked out a 0.84% gain. Year to date bonds in the STC Index are up 4.04%, while money market/stable value offerings are up 2.55%.
Perhaps as a result of the performance disparity, STC experienced a 10% increase of funds into money market and stable value funds in the third quarter, while large cap growth funds suffered a 25% decrease.
Ticker “Tape”
Year to date, self-directed brokerage accounts in the STC Index have registered an average annualized loss of 10.60%, compared with a loss of 11.95% for separately managed options, and a 15.20% decline for the returns in core option mutual funds. For the same period, the S&P 500 was down more than 28%.
Security Trust Company is the nation’s largest independent trust and custody company, providing institutional back-office trust services to financial service providers and their customers. The Phoenix-based company was founded in 1991.