Never miss a story — sign up for PLANSPONSOR newsletters to keep up on the latest retirement plan benefits news.
Benchmarking Financial Wellness Offerings as a Qualitative Practice
Industry insiders suggest looking at products beyond the metrics.
Plan sponsors increasingly view financial wellness and emergency savings offerings as workforce-management tools that support both employee well-being and organizational performance. But with a vast world of providers and benefits offerings to choose from, sponsors can benchmark not only quantitative data—but qualitative, as well—to ensure their organization and its employees are getting the best value for their dollar.
4 Dimensions of Wellness
Sid Pailla, CEO and founder of financial wellness company Sunny Day Fund, says there are four main areas within financial wellness for sponsors to benchmark: financial literacy offerings, financial coaching and advice services, debt management capabilities and emergency savings accounts—Sunny Day’s main offering.
Benchmarking has long been an exercise of “checking a single box,” Pailla says, but he advises sponsors check boxes across all four dimensions. Determining the success of an ESA, for instance, should include measuring how costly an emergency an employee’s savings can cover, Pailla says.
Within each dimension of wellness, Pailla says, sponsors conducting first-time or ongoing evaluation of a product should ask themselves what the respective offerings’ capabilities are, what outcomes they have proven to drive and what other sponsors’ experiences with them have been.
Sponsor Perspectives
Before deciding to choose Sunny Day, Al Perreca, vice president of support services and commercial flooring at Romanoff Renovations, started by speaking with several ESA providers at an industry meeting. After that, he held a series of calls with each firm and spoke with other plan sponsors about their experiences with each of the providers, to help narrow down his options.
Perreca says his best recommendation to another sponsor vetting firms and products is to speak with other companies that are using the provider under consideration. Understanding the experience of companies of similar sizes especially, he says, can be an important part of the decision-making process.
Typically, Perreca says, his company offers a product for a year before evaluating how well it works for employees. In addition, several months before a product or service is up for renewal, he typically pulls data to see how well-utilized it is.
Perreca usually measures the success and value of offering a tool based on both employee enrollment and participation. Between 50% and 60% of Romanoff employees have opened an ESA account since the firm adopted Sunny Day, Perreca says, much higher than the utilization he saw for an emergency resource Romanoff offered before Sunny Day.
Jess Pancoast, a human resources business partner at Genuine Foods Co., says she reviews employee participation and the number of employee referrals to Sunny Day to help determine whether the offering is successful for her employee base.
Aside from metrics, Pancoast says she solicits qualitative internal feedback from employees and external feedback from sponsors at conferences and other industry events. She typically tries to ask for feedback from sponsors operating in industries with similar demographics to hers.
Pancoast evaluates, year-to-year, whether participation in a program increases. Before continuing to offer a program, she likes to make sure there is growth in adoption, as opposed to just a consistent “handful” of employees using any one offering.
Making a ‘Shopping’ List
Kelli Send, co-founder of and senior vice president of financial wellness services at Francis LLC, calls benchmarking financial wellness offerings a “shopping process.” While shopping for providers, she recommends sponsors ask potential candidates how they would show that their product is driving change for employees. A sponsor can ask for tools to measure individual improvement in financial wellness.
To conduct an ongoing assessment of a product, Send says employers can deploy surveys to ask employees whether the benefit is helpful, using both qualitative and quantitative questions. She says utilization metrics, such as plan data, can be informative to a plan sponsor, but she cautions against relying solely upon them.
“A lack of engagement in emergency savings does not translate to, ‘I am good on emergency savings,’” Send says. “You have to ask the participant.”





