Markets Narrow S&P 500 Pension Funding Gap
May 27, 2011 (PLANSPONSOR.com) – While the global market rebound in 2010 was certainly a welcome respite for pension funding, it didn’t do much to close the gap in S&P 500 pensions.
According a new report by S&P Indices, the underfunding position in S&P 500 pensions improved slightly to a $245 billion shortfall, compared with $261 billion in 2009, despite the boost from a 12.4% global market rebound. Additionally, according to the report, “S&P 500 2010: Pensions and Other Post Employment Benefits (OPEB)“, OPEB remains severely underfunded at $210 billion.
The report notes that the pension funding rate increased to 83.9% from 81.7%, the discount rate declined to 5.31% from 5.81%, increasing projected obligations, and the expected return rate declined to 7.73% from 7.83% the year previously.
“Even with a 15% equity return and a market recovery of over 45% over the past two years, S&P 500 companies still could not put a dent into the pension underfunding situation,” says Howard Silverblatt, S&P Senior Index Analyst and author of the report. “However, there is a faint light at the end of this tunnel. Because of the record recovery in 2010, companies are currently in much better shape to handle corporate pensions – now considered an acceptable and manageable expense well within their income and assets levels.”
The S&P Indices report also reviewed the status of Other Post Employment Benefits (OPEB). Within the S&P 500, 296 companies offered OPEBs in 2010. With $274.1 billion in OPEB obligations, only $64.5 billion was funded. While OPEB funding levels have increased in recent years, its funding status (23.53%) still pales in comparison to that of pensions (83.9%), according to the report.
Combined, the amount of assets that S&P 500 companies set aside in 2010 to fund pensions and OPEBs amounted to $1.34 trillion, covering $1.79 trillion in obligations with the resulting underfunding equating to $ 455.1 billion, or a 25.5% funding rate.
The report notes that corporate contributions were again “much larger than expected”, with $68.4 billion in 2010, more than twice the $33.2 billion anticipated for that year. S&P Indices noted that the same scenario occurred in 2009, with $ 66.1 billion contributed, compared to the expectation of $38.7 billion. “The additional contributions were in stark contrast to the prior contributions, which averaged $ 36.7 billion over the prior nine years,” according to the report, which went on to note that for 2011 companies have increased their anticipated contribution to $ 41.1 billion – a number that the report says, based on the market’s year-to-date performance, should be sufficient. “However, markets change,” it cautions.
The report notes that OPEB underfunding remains “massive”, even as underfunding was reduced to $210 billion from $ 215 billion. The report noted that only four companies are fully overfunded.
However, the report notes that S&P 500 pension costs have now “become a reasonably-controlled expense to corporations, with costs and outflows fitting well within income and assets levels, as well as, cash-flow”. S&P Indices however, believes that the current state of the regulated pension system “includes archaic accounting regulations that distort the financial position of pension funds and their sponsors, in addition to, a pay-as-you-go OPEB system with very little funding or legal guarantees”.
The report’s authors predicted that the shift to defined contribution designs will result in a “legacy program which over the next several decades will mostly work its way out of the last bastions of the U.S. labor market, and out of existence”.
You Might Also Like:

Union Pension Funding Crisis Solution Remains Elusive

It’s Back to Basics for Benefits Priorities
