PLANSPONSOR Webinar: Understanding Participant Behavior

Panelists discussed the attitudes, actions and preferences of today’s retirement plan participants.

There is no cookie-cutter solution to driving participant engagement, but there are ingredients to success, according to panelists at the recent PLANSPONSOR webinar “Driving Participant Engagement.”

Speakers discussed how to drive positive plan outcomes based on the attitudes, actions and preferences of today’s retirement plan participants.

Never miss a story — sign up for PLANSPONSOR newsletters to keep up on the latest retirement plan benefits news.

Empirical Measures

Craig Copeland, director of wealth benefits research at the Employee Benefit Research Institute, said his No. 1 recommendation for any plan sponsor is to know its workforce. He says some plan features will work better with certain workforces than others, requiring close attention.

The “most obvious” way to increase participant engagement, Copeland said, is for plans to utilize automatic enrollment—a practice made mandatory for most new plans through the enactment of the SECURE 2.0 Act of 2022.

He added that EBRI research has shown that the contribution rate at which participants are defaulted into a plan tends not to affect whether they opt out. With this, Copeland recommended plans also use auto-escalation, which increases participants’ contribution rates in intervals, such as once a year.

In addition, he said he urges plans to conduct auto-re-enrollment, which places employees who previously opted out of the plan back into it at the default contribution rate. He explained that re-enrollment can help plans pick up participants whose financial situations may have improved since the time they chose to opt out.

Deanna Allison, director of benefits, well-being and financial programs at Bread Financial, said participant engagement can actually be measured by missed engagement. She recommends “reverse engineering” an 85% enrollment rate, for instance, to focus on the 15% of participants that are not enrolled.

To reach that 15%, Allison said it is important for sponsors to understand that they have to help participants build positive habits and take action to improve their savings.

“It’s important to understand that [if] the best programs with the biggest budgets feel complicated, intimidating or boring, that won’t work,” Allison said. “You have to make the [material] approachable.”

Optimism About Saving

Doug Kincaid, head of thought leadership and managing director of financial services at Greenwald Research, said recent research he conducted shows six in 10 participants say they are saving less than they need, with the top reason for undersaving being cost of living. He said he would expect that to be participants’ sentiment in 2027 as well.

Most surprising, in Kincaid’s view, is that 41% of those who said they are behind on saving say it would be easy for them to save more. Half of all participants said it would be easy to save more, and one-third of non-participants said it would be easy for them to start.

“Auto features are raising the floor for saving,” Kincaid said. “But when this many people are self-identifying as not saving enough, [yet saying] it would be easy for them to do it, it’s an engagement problem, not simply an ability problem.”

Kincaid says another problem he sees is that participants wait too long to engage in certain planning tasks. In a survey, his organization asked retirees whether they completed nine key planning tasks before retiring, several of which included “fundamental” tasks such as calculating how much they would need to save for retirement and identifying a target retirement age, as well as more complex actions like creating a written plan.

The results, Kincaid said, were shocking: five years before retirement, none of the tasks had been completed by even half of the respondents. Most of the activity occurred in the final two years before retirement, which Kincaid said can be tricky, as it leaves little room to course-correct.

To motivate employees to increase their savings, Kincaid said his research has shown that employees’ top request was to have a clearer vision of the lifestyle they would be able to afford if they increased their savings by a certain amount. Employees in their 50s and 60s—those closer to retirement—were especially likely to want a more concrete vision.

To help with this, Kincaid says he recommends sponsors help participants “foster the identity of a saver.”

Removing the Barriers to Action

Lindsay Madaras, a senior manager of associate well-being at Bread Financial, said one of the most important concepts her organization has learned is that participants do not necessarily need more information—they need fewer barriers to acting on information they have.

Bread follows three principles when it comes to communication and engagement, according to Madaras: “no shame, making it easy and making it fun.”

“No shame” means never making a participant feel bad for only contributing a small percentage of pay to their 401(k), Madaras explained. It removes the “emotional barrier.”

“We want to help [participants] build confidence, not guilt, and really give them the tools they need to make better decisions that they feel good about and that will hopefully put them in a position to do more when they’re ready to do more,” Madaras said.

Madaras said that as part of following the “no shame” philosophy, Bread launched an in-plan emergency savings account with T. Rowe Price. Bread wanted its employees to not only save for the future but be confident with their ability to handle immediate expenses.

As for “making it easy,” Madaras said Bread tries to remove as much of the friction to enjoying benefits as possible. For example, Bread always offers its financial education workshops on paid company time so that employees have dedicated time to focus on them. The firm also tries to use plain language whenever possible when explaining benefits and potentially unfamiliar terms to employees.

For Bread, “making it fun” includes leaning into creative puns, Madaras explained. When the firm deposited its annual contributions into employee accounts, for instance, it sent participants a message that said, “we just dropped some dough in your account,” capitalizing on Bread’s foody name.

The company also found ways to make light of seemingly unfun activities, Madaras said. To encourage employees to add a beneficiary to their retirement account, Bread sent a Halloween-themed email that said, “Don’t ghost your loved ones.” After a year-long campaign prompting employees to name their beneficiaries, Bread had a 10-percentage-point increase in the number of employees with a beneficiary on file.

“I think fun gets attention, which then creates an opportunity for engagement, and then leads to action,” Madaras said.

«