Layoffs Slow, but More Salary, Benefits Cuts to Come

February 25, 2009 (PLANSPONSOR.com) - A new update to an ongoing series of surveys conducted by Watson Wyatt shows that most companies have already made most of the sweeping changes they intend to, although many expect to make further cost-cutting changes this year, such as salary and hiring freezes, and reduced 401(k) matching contributions.

“With over half of companies reporting they have already made layoffs, they are now focusing on smaller, more sustainable cost-cutting actions,” said Laura Sejen, global director of strategic rewards consulting at Watson Wyatt, in a press release. According to the survey of 245 large U.S. employers conducted last week, 52% have made layoffs, up from 39% two months ago; however, the number of companies planning future layoffs has fallen from 23% to 13%.

Meanwhile, according to the press release, the survey showed 56% of firms now have a hiring freeze in effect, an increase from 47% in December’s survey. There has been a jump in the number of companies that have put into place other changes as well, including salary freezes (up to 42% of respondents now from 13% in December’s survey); reductions in 401(k) matches (up to 12% from 3%); a shortened workweek (up to 13% from 2%) and travel restrictions (up to 69% from 48%).

Survey results also show that the majority of companies (61%) expect the downturn in their performance to last at least until the end of 2009. Approximately half of companies (51%) plan to increase their cost-cutting actions in 2009 and beyond.

Other findings from the survey include:

  • Planned merit increases are now 1.7%, less than half of what companies originally planned before the recession hit. Of those who have revised their budgets, 58% did so in the last two months.
  • Of those who have already made layoffs, 29% have offered enhanced severance benefits such as extended benefits coverage, extended pay or extended job search assistance.
  • Since the economic crisis hit, 79% of respondents have noticed 401(k) or 403(b) participants changing their investment mix to move out of equities (up from 59% in December’s survey); 45% have seen an increase in the number of loans taken (up from 27% in December’s survey); and 35% have seen an increase in the number of hardship withdrawals taken (up from 16% in December’s survey).
  • Short-term incentive funding has not changed substantially since October – from a mean of 86% funded last year, current annual bonus pools stand at 71% funded.

Companies continue to change a variety of HR programs in response to cost pressures

align="center"> Already made change

align="center"> Expecting to make change

align="center"> Feb

align="center"> 2009

align="center"> Dec

align="center"> 2008

align="center"> Oct

align="center"> 2008

align="center"> Feb

align="center"> 2009

align="center"> Dec

align="center"> 2008

align="center"> Oct

align="center"> 2008

Add/increase restrictions to company travel policy

align="center"> 69%

align="center"> 48%

align="center"> 34%

align="center"> 10%

align="center"> 16%

align="center"> 21%

Hiring freeze

align="center"> 56%

align="center"> 47%

align="center"> 30%

align="center"> 10%

align="center"> 18%

align="center"> 25%

Layoffs/reduction in force

align="center"> 52%

align="center"> 39%

align="center"> 19%

align="center"> 13%

align="center"> 23%

align="center"> 26%

Eliminate or reduce the hiring of seasonal workers

align="center"> 44%

align="center"> 28%

align="center"> 17%

align="center"> 9%

align="center"> 16%

align="center"> 18%

Salary freeze

align="center"> 42%

align="center"> 13%

align="center"> 4%

align="center"> 14%

align="center"> 19%

align="center"> 12%

Eliminate or reduce training programs

align="center"> 35%

align="center"> 23%

align="center"> 10%

align="center"> 15%

align="center"> 18%

align="center"> 18%

Organization-wide restructuring

align="center"> 31%

align="center"> 23%

align="center"> 14%

align="center"> 20%

align="center"> 21%

align="center"> 23%

Increase communication to employees about their benefits

align="center"> 31%

align="center"> 32%

align="center"> 35%

align="center"> 27%

align="center"> 35%

align="center"> 35%

Increase communication to employees about their pay

align="center"> 28%

align="center"> 16%

align="center"> 18%

align="center"> 31%

align="center"> 43%

align="center"> 37%

HR function restructuring

align="center"> 23%

align="center"> 14%

align="center"> 15%

align="center"> 22%

align="center"> 21%

align="center"> 19%

Reduce/eliminate other employee programs (tuition reimbursement, subsidized dining facilities, etc.)

align="center"> 23%

align="center"> 12%

align="center"> 8%

align="center"> 18%

align="center"> 12%

align="center"> 11%

Raise percentage that employees pay for health care premiums

align="center"> 22%

align="center"> 20%

align="center"> 21%

align="center"> 24%

align="center"> 17%

align="center"> 25%

Reduced workweek

align="center"> 13%

align="center"> 2%

align="center"> 4%

align="center"> 8%

align="center"> 6%

align="center"> 4%

Reduce employer 401(k)/403(b) match

align="center"> 12%

align="center"> 3%

align="center"> 2%

align="center"> 12%

align="center"> 7%

align="center"> 4%

Salary reductions

align="center"> 7%

align="center"> 5%

align="center"> 2%

align="center"> 4%

align="center"> 6%

align="center"> 4%

Early retirement window

align="center"> 6%

align="center"> 3%

align="center"> 4%

align="center"> 6%

align="center"> 6%

align="center"> 5%

«