Compliance June 5, 2015
PSNC: Avoiding Lawsuits
It’s often simply a lack of oversight and processes not followed.
Reported by Judy Faust Hartnett
Before the Enron scandal that resulted in the increased accountability of auditing firms to remain unbiased and independent of their clients, there was relatively little litigation in the retirement plan arena. But this has changed, as was the perception of 64% of attendees polled at the PLANSPONSOR National Conference in Chicago, who indicated that litigation risk is increasing in this industry.
Jamie Fleckner, a partner at Goodwin Procter LLP, said “plaintiff’s lawyers have become more interested in lawsuits because of the increased assets in defined contribution (DC) plans, with the focus of the suits against plan sponsors and providers.”
But lawsuits also arise when problems come up with loans, deferrals and distributions according to Scott Liggett JD, Director, ERISA oversight, at Lawing Financial Inc. Qualified Plan Advisors.
“A lot of times it’s simply issues with day-to-day activities of the plan and a lack of oversight and processes not followed,” Liggett said. “This is above and beyond fee share class issues.”
In order to get processes in place, Fleckner said, a plan sponsor can hire lawyers or independent fiduciaries, but this is not always feasible, especially for small plans.
“Or plan sponsors can get an investment policy statement (IPS) to help manage the plan,” Fleckner said. “But importantly, if you create the document, you must always consider it and not just put it on the shelf.
What does a quality document look like? Liggett said: “You don’t want to paint yourself into a corner. At the end of the day, those who look at plan documents such as an IPS, need to have them be understandable. At the same time, they should not be overgeneralized—not when or what needs to be done, for instance, that does not help.”
Jamie Fleckner, a partner at Goodwin Procter LLP, said “plaintiff’s lawyers have become more interested in lawsuits because of the increased assets in defined contribution (DC) plans, with the focus of the suits against plan sponsors and providers.”
But lawsuits also arise when problems come up with loans, deferrals and distributions according to Scott Liggett JD, Director, ERISA oversight, at Lawing Financial Inc. Qualified Plan Advisors.
“A lot of times it’s simply issues with day-to-day activities of the plan and a lack of oversight and processes not followed,” Liggett said. “This is above and beyond fee share class issues.”
In order to get processes in place, Fleckner said, a plan sponsor can hire lawyers or independent fiduciaries, but this is not always feasible, especially for small plans.
“Or plan sponsors can get an investment policy statement (IPS) to help manage the plan,” Fleckner said. “But importantly, if you create the document, you must always consider it and not just put it on the shelf.
What does a quality document look like? Liggett said: “You don’t want to paint yourself into a corner. At the end of the day, those who look at plan documents such as an IPS, need to have them be understandable. At the same time, they should not be overgeneralized—not when or what needs to be done, for instance, that does not help.”
You Might Also Like:
DOL Answers Appeal in ESG Rule Litigation
The ESG rule was upheld in a Texas district court, but was appealed to the 5th Circuit in October 2023.
Advocates for DOL Fiduciary Proposal Say Existing Insurance Regulations Fall Short
The proposal would add a private right of action and tighter conflict of interest rules.
DOL Says Central States Must Repay $127M SFA Overpayment
Central States was granted $127 million that it was not entitled to because the PBGC counted over 3,000 deceased participants...