For more stories like this, sign up for the PLANSPONSOR NEWSDash daily newsletter.
Survey Finds TPA Revenue Sharing Disclosures, Audits Lacking
The Survey of Third Party Retirement Administrators by McHenry Consulting reveals that revenue sharing arrangements are generally (69%) not disclosed to customers on a regular basis, and just 16% obtain a SAS-70 audit of their recordkeeping systems and procedures.
A majority of the 275 respondents (52%) do not support company stock administration.
A full 25% of the respondents draw more than 80% of their business from daily valued defined contribution plans. Roughly a third (32%) use an outside service provider or partner to offer this service.
To better compete with bundled provider offerings, the TPA respondents now offered the following services:
- 18% – Employee Education
- 14% – Internet Access
- 12% – Online Account Lookup
- 11% – Online Transactions
- 11% – Toll-free Access to Call Center
- 10% – Interactive Voice Response
- 5%s – Online Investment Advice
Trend Lines
- NSCC Mutual Fund Trading had a positive impact on 44% of the respondents’ business, but 49% registered a neutral impact.
- A positive impact from a consolidated “super” statement was reported by 47%, with 44% indicating no impact.
- Self-directed brokerage accounts registered a positive impact for nearly 3/4 of the respondents (74%). Schwab was identified by most as the broker of choice (30%), while Fidelity came in second at 19% and Merrill Lynch at 14%. “Other” was noted by 22%.
Respondent Demographics
Respondents tended to be smaller firms, with nearly half (44%) employing 10 or fewer employees. Those employing 10 to 49 workers comprised another 41% of the total.
Forty-one percent of the respondents used the Quantech software, 14% Datair, 9% Trustmark and 9% FDP. Just 1% used OmniPlan/Plus, a mainstay of larger recordkeepers.
Nearly a quarter (24%) are considering a change in that software vendor over the next 18 months, with another 23% “somewhat likely” to do so.