Participants See the Benefits of Diversification Amid Pandemic
First quarter performance data shows well designed defined contribution retirement plans are doing a decent job at protecting the savings of working Americans relative to retail brokerage accounts.
At this stage, reports abound showing the damage done to the equity markets by the coronavirus pandemic.
After a record-breaking bull run, investors at one point in the first quarter saw the S&P 500 touching levels 30% below its February 19 peak. The markets have rebounded some since that time, but they remain depressed and volatile.
Indeed, according to Fidelity’s internal analysis of first quarter performance, the coronavirus market downturn caused average 401(k), individual retirement account (IRA) and 403(b) balances to drop. The average 401(k) balance was $91,400, down 19% from the record high of $112,300 in Q4 2019, but still higher than the Q1 2010 balance of $71,500 seen in the wake of the Great Recession.
The average IRA balance was $98,900, a 14% decrease from last quarter but also higher than the Q1 2010 balance of $66,200. The average 403(b)/tax exempt account balance was $75,700, down 19% from last quarter but still above the average balance of $50,000 in Q1 2010.
Discussing these figures with PLANSPONSOR, Katie Taylor, Fidelity vice president for thought leadership, says the numbers are painful to see in one sense, but at the same time they actually underscore the fantastic work being done by retirement plan sponsors and advisers.
“The numbers show that people in the defined contribution (DC) marketplace have access to some very well-designed plans that allow them to diversify and protect their investments,” Taylor suggests. “It is also encouraging that we see very clear evidence that people are sticking with their long-term strategies within retirement plans, in no small part due to the communication and education efforts of plan sponsors and advisers.”
One remarkable fact in the Fidelity reporting from Q1 is that investors actually opened IRAs at record pace, with more than 407,000 new accounts opened at Fidelity alone. And, according to Fidelity’s data, contributions to IRAs among Millennials increased a whopping 64% over Q1 2019.
“It is so encouraging to see that many investors stayed the course and did not make drastic changes to their asset allocations, with some investors increasing contributions to their retirement accounts,” Taylor observes. “However, we know that investors continue to be concerned about how the economic environment and global pandemic may impact their health and financial futures, and we are already seeing the impact of the market downturn on our clients.”
Another bright spot in the markets has been the relative outperformance of investment funds with environmental, social and governance (ESG) mandates, as observed by Nigel Green, the chief executive and founder of deVere Group. Economic and social upheaval, plus the collapse of oil prices, have pushed responsible and impactful investing further into mainstream finance, he says.
“Even before the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, ESG investments often outperformed the market and had lower volatility over the long run,” Green says. “What is perhaps more impressive is that those investments with robust ESG credentials are still typically continuing to outperform throughout the coronavirus-triggered stock market crashes where major indices were extremely volatile, with some plummeting 20%. Clearly, this is going to increasingly attract both retail and institutional investors seeking decent returns in turbulent times.”
Green speculates that the collapse of oil prices, which he says are likely not to rebound to pre-crisis levels in the short term, has also helped drive ESG investments to the top of the performance charts and keep them there.
“This is because ESG funds circumnavigate oil stocks, so their performance will not be adversely impacted by the fall in share prices,” he says. “There is a wider and growing force behind the rise of environmental, social and governance investing. The current situation has acted as a wake-up call in many respects. It underscores that human health is reliant upon healthy ecosystems, that we need to ensure the sustainability of supply chains and that those companies with robust corporate governance and good business practice fare better in difficult times and are ultimately best-positioned for the future.”
« Financial Wellness Will Be the New Priority Following the Pandemic