Vanguard Proposes SECURE 3.0 Policy Suggestions

A new paper recommends that Congress focus on retirement savers starting work and changing jobs.

Policymakers have shaped workplace retirement saving by enacting the Setting Every Community up for Retirement Enhancement Act of 2019 and the SECURE 2.0 Act of 2022, but a new Vanguard paper suggests the journey is not over. 

“Six Big Ideas for Improving U.S. Retirement Outcomes,” released on Monday, proposes that, as part of a potential SECURE 3.0 Act, Congress consider increasing employee participation as they start work and maintain savings momentum as they change jobs. 

Never miss a story — sign up for PLANSPONSOR newsletters to keep up on the latest retirement plan benefits news.

“There has been a ton of progress … and policy change that has advanced the retirement system, and yet we still see opportunity,” says Fiona Greig, one of the report’s co-authors and principal and global head of investor research in Vanguard’s investor strategy group. “Only two in five people are on track to be ready for retirement.” 

Increasing Participation 

The Vanguard paper proposed that employers be required to provide access to payroll deductions into individual retirement accounts. By doing so, Vanguard stated that the participation gap would close by 60% for the roughly 65 million workers who either lack access to or do not participate in an employer-sponsored retirement account. 

The proposal could provide about 22.7 million newly covered workers with an average of about $90,000 in retirement savings by age 65, the paper stated. The estimate assumes annual contributions of $742 over 40 years and a 5% real annual return. 

Vanguard also suggested that policymakers expand automatic enrollment requirements to existing employer-sponsored plans, excluding small businesses, and requiring plans to periodically re-enroll workers. SECURE 2.0 required only newly created retirement plans to auto-enroll workers and excluded both businesses with 10 or fewer employees and businesses in existence for less than three years. 

The paper estimated that expanding auto-enrollment requirements would generate nearly 17 million new participants with as much as $186,000 in additional retirement savings by age 65. This assumes an annual increase in retirement savings of $1,540 over a 40-year career and a 5% real annual return. 

Opting for Defaults 

Greig says a “second bucket” of proposals is about removing frictions from the retirement system, including by allowing default investment options for IRAs. Vanguard estimated that implementing the policy could help move about 6.5 million rollovers and 12.5 million contributions held in cash each year, addressing the issue that 28% of rollover investors leave their funds in cash for seven years or longer. 

“What we’re asking for is very simple,” Greig says. “We’re asking for default investment options to exist in IRAs just as they do in 401(k) plans.” 

Greig says the default investments her firm proposed should apply to both IRA contributions and rollovers. 

Vanguard projected the proposal would yield an expected $51,000 on average in additional retirement savings by age 65 across a career with multiple rollovers, in addition to about $7,000 in additional retirement savings by age 65 for a worker who contributes to their plan every year, at a 5% real annual return. 

The paper also addressed what Greig calls “low default savings rates,” by increasing the default saving rate to 6%. Currently, about 27.7 million workers in plans automatically enroll below the 6% threshold. However, more plans than ever—31%—now automatically enroll workers at a default rate of 6% or more, according to Vanguard’s 2026 “How America Saves” report. 

Keep Saving Momentum Going 

Another proposal addresses the “fine print,” Greig says: being ineligible to make and receive contributions until a certain period of time has passed. 

Requiring immediate eligibility for employee and employer contributions would minimize periods during which workers are unable to contribute to or receive employer contributions in a retirement plan, helping them maintain saving momentum throughout their careers, according to the paper.  

Over the last 10 years, the share of plans granting immediate eligibility for employee contributions has increased to 77% from 68%, while the share allowing employers to immediately contribute has increased to 66% from 54%, according to data from Vanguard. 

Vanguard also called for immediate vesting. According to the paper, vesting forfeitures occur in about 30% of job separations and disproportionately impact lower-income participants, reducing their balances by roughly 40%. 

“Immediate vesting would ensure that workers do not forfeit employer contributions when they change jobs, helping them preserve accumulated retirement wealth throughout their careers,” the paper stated. 

Switching Jobs 

The last “friction,” Greig says, concerns portability. 

Vanguard stated that standard account portability could yield $14,000 in additional retirement savings by age 65 for the 17.5 million workers in defined contribution plans who switch jobs each year. Roughly 28% of workers cash out their retirement savings when they leave a job, according to data from Vanguard. 

To improve account portability and help workers consolidate assets, policymakers could expand automatic portability for larger balances, create standardized digital infrastructure for all plan-to-plan and plan-to-IRA rollovers or pursue both approaches, the paper suggested. 

Official Bids for SECURE 3.0 

Bids for SECURE 3.0 legislation began early last month, when Representatives Bobby Scott, D-Virginia, and Mark DeSaulnier, D-California, introduced three bills addressing retirement plan participants’ standing to sue, the definition of “fiduciary” and mandatory arbitration clauses.   

Additionally, on November 10, Senators Todd Young, R-Indiana, and Cory Booker, D-New Jersey, introduced the Optimizing Participant Tax Incentives Through Optional Noncash Selections Act, referred to as the “OPTIONS Act,” which would amend the Internal Revenue Code to allow employees to choose how certain employer contributions are allocated. Workers could choose among retirement savings, student loan repayment, health savings accounts, health reimbursement arrangements and other eligible benefits. 

The legislation is intended “to give American workers greater flexibility in how they receive employer-provided benefits,” according to a press release from Young’s office. The bill would essentially codify an IRS private letter ruling from 2024. 

Representatives Greg Steube, R-Florida, and Suzan DelBene, D-Washington, introduced a companion bill in the Senate in April. 

The American Retirement Association, the Chief Human Resources Officer Association and the ERISA Industry Committee were among trade groups that expressed statements in support of the bill.

«